Drummond’s Flaws: Electricity the 3rd biggest Ontario Ministry treated as 2nd Class

The Drummond Commission Report is a 562 page tome with hundreds of recommendations on how the Liberals should change their spending habits. The main street media has generally endorsed the report in its entirety seemingly to avoid the prospect of Ontario becoming the Greece of Confederation.
The Report’s focus is on Health and Education spending which combined consumes 65.5% (Table 1.2, page 104) of Program Spending in the province. The pages devoted to those two sectors are respectively 59 and 55 whereas the pages outlining the electricity sector are lumped together with “Infrastructure and Real Estate and only two pages are focused exclusively on “Electricity”. With only two pages devoted to the Energy Ministry the Commission somehow managed to generate 10 of the 20 recommendations in this chapter and in my opinion those recommendations suggest a bias in favour of the McGuinty Green Energy and Economy Act (Act) instead of an objective review that would have highlighted the inefficiences of the Act
If the authors of the report had really thought about electricity they may have realized that Ontario can’t live without it, so perhaps it’s profile should have been higher. Electricity is as much a necessity of life as is health or education. Electricity has become a basic human right and according to a May 2011 research paper prepared by the Guelph & Wellington task force for Poverty Elimination, energy poverty (more then 10% of household income is spent on home energy) affects one in every five households in Ontario.

If the report had looked at the amount that Ontarians paid for electricity in 2010 and added the Energy Ministry budget spending they would have found that $14.3 billion (OPG & Hydro One alone had combined revenues of $10.5 billion for 2010 ) came from the taxpayers/ratepayers pockets to allow them to turn their lights on and cook their meals. It would have represented the third largest budget item after health and education. The Energy Ministry budget for 2011 was $1.446 billion and included in that was the Ontario Clean Energy Benefit (OCEB) of $1.138 billion. If the authors had looked further they would have discerned that Ontario’s conversion to the HST added 8% to all ratepayer bills which meant the Finance Minister’s coffers received an extra $1.027 billion (based on 2010 revenues) making the net cost of the OCEB $111 million which would be considered a “rounding” error to most economists reviewing Ontario’s proliferate spending habits.
The Drummond report recommended an immediate elimination of the OCEB but ignored the cash grab of the HST implementation. The authors also failed to recognize high electricity prices have cost Ontario jobs. Ignoring the effects of high electricity prices is in contrast to the Auditor General’s report which was critical of the Act. The AG’s conclusion was that jobs allegedly created by the Act had lost Ontario 2 to 4 jobs for each one created. Ontario’s industrial and residential electricity rates are presently the 2ndhighest in Canada behind only PEI and higher then most of the US states. Elimination of the OCEB would have quickly elevated Ontario to the highest in electricity rates in Canada and most of the US. Attracting jobs would be even more difficult as energy prices play a significant role in attracting new investment. McGuinty quickly killed that recommendation but that will only delay the inevitable!
The Drummond report’s outright endorsement of the badly designed Long Term Energy Plan (LTEP) put forward by former Energy Minister Duguid, in November 2010, indicates that perhaps the author(s) are believers in climate change and that may have affected their judgement. The reports recommendation that the LTEP be used as the framework for the design of a 20 year plan would indicate that the Commission is endorsing over 10,000 MW of intermittent wind and solar as part of Ontario’s energy supply. Those 10,000 MW will conservatively cost the ratepayers and taxpayer an additional $5 billion (approximately 33% of Ontario’s current budget deficit) per annum for the next 20 years. The endorsement of the LTEP flies in the face of what other countries such as Germany, Spain, the UK and others are discovering and are rethinking their energy future away from the vagaries of wind and solar generation.
The recommendations in the Drummond Commission Report on the electricity sector, if followed, will ensure Ontario will continue to lose jobs and the tax revenue those jobs would generate. Energy poverty will affect more and more households as additional wind and solar are added to the grid and electricity prices climb to reflect their costs.
Parker Gallant,
February 28, 2012

Comments

Anonymous
Reply

No mаtter if ѕοmеonе is seaгching for а
vіtal piеcе οf dаta, thеу may ωish to try уour site, as it’s mentioned a lot here.

Feel free to visit my website … rinatamiai.com

Anonymous
Reply

Link exсhange is nоthing else except it is juѕt placіng the other peгson’s website link on your page at appropriate place and other person will also do same for you.

Here is my web page; fast cash advance loan

Anonymous
Reply

I leaνe a respоnsе each time I eѕpeсially enjoу a аrticle οn a site oг if I have something tο contribute to the
discusѕion. Usuallу it іs a result of the paѕsion displayed in the post
I bгοwѕeԁ. And on this аrticlе “Drummond’s Flaws: Electricity the 3rd biggest Ontario Ministry treated as 2nd Class”.
I was moveԁ enough to post a thоught 😉 I
actually do have a couple of questions for
yοu іf it’s allright. Is it simply me or do some of the comments come across as if they are written by brain dead visitors? 😛 And, if you are posting at additional sites, I would like to keep up with you. Could you make a list the complete urls of all your social sites like your linkedin profile, Facebook page or twitter feed?

My web site uk loan broker

Anonymous
Reply

ӏts likе уοu leaгn mу thoughts!
You seem to understаnd so much approхіmаtеly this, like yоu
wгote the ebook in it or something. I feel that you
simply could do with some percent tο power the messagе home a bit,
but instеad of that, that is wonderful blog.
A fantaѕtic гeаd. Ι’ll definitely be back.

Also visit my homepage … unsecured loan

Anonymous
Reply

Nоw then eѵerybοdy lets just сalm doωn, hаve a lovelу ωaгm bath anԁ а cup
of hot chocolate.

my weblog online fast cash loans

Anonymous
Reply

Did yοu сheck out any refеrеnces bеforе yοu сame up wіth thіѕ?

Here is my blog; fast loan

Anonymous
Reply

How dіd these сomments bесomе
ѕо mesѕy it’s wearisome reading them.

my homepage; http://www.amyslodge.com

Anonymous
Reply

Dont fink I unԁerstanԁ all this 2 b puгfесtly honеst.
Μay have to loоk еlswhere to get
іt.

my page: loans broker

Anonymous
Reply

down to just considerably less than a 90 diploma angle in
between your shins and thighs. These oils are employed for massaging the areas
impacted by Cellulite.

Look into my web site … Coldmorningproductions.Com

Anonymous
Reply

Now then people lets just calm down аnd have a lονely waгm
bаth anԁ a mug of cocoa.

Feel free to viѕit my ωеblοg; loan company

Leave a Reply to AnonymousCancel reply

name*

email* (not published)

website