How to spend $4.7 billion ratepayer dollars

$4.7 billion? I'll read it later--the Sens are playing
$4.7 billion? I’ll read it later–the Sens are playing

A Liberal cost/benefit plan or, how to “plan” to spend $4.7 billion ratepayer dollars

Give Energy Minister, Bob Chiarelli a nice pie (chart) and he will be happy.  He gave his blessing to the proposed OPA Business Plan to spend $4.2 billion ratepayer dollars—all nicely pictured in a pie chart that doesn’t include spending $483 million on “conservation” initiatives.

The plan was submitted Friday January 24, 2014 and was approved by Chiarelli on Tuesday, January 29, 2012.  Guess he worked over the weekend studying the chart?  Figure 2 (the chart) in the Plan provides a breakdown of planned 2014 electricity spending on those “generation charges of $4,242 million” plus another chart laying out the $483 million to be spent on conservation.

OPA Business Plan Figure 2.
OPA Business Plan Figure 2.


Green is for clean-23% ($975.6 million);  Blue is for Renewable-32% ($1,357.4 million) and puce is for nuclear-45% (1,909 million)!  The Chart as noted represents $4,242 million ratepayer dollars to be spent in 2014.

The chart from the 2014−2016 OPA Business Plan was filed with the OEB, as file number EB-2013-0326.  The OPA’s budget for their operational expenditures ($60.3 million) was also included in the submission and approved by the OEB December 19, 2013.  The 40-page submission uses buzz words rather than actual economic analysis or a cost-benefit study.  For example, you will find “partner” or  partnership and partners 57 times, “initiatives” 55 times, “ensure” 22 times, “cost-effective” 20 times,  “communication” 24 times, and “solution” 21 times.

The last of 12 listed as “most significant initiatives” is this:  “continuing efforts to further reduce expenses and the cost impact of operations on electricity consumers.”  So “cost impact” on electricity consumers is at the bottom of the heap. Not likely to change with the Liberal majority government.

You also find the OPA’s “Vision” statement in the Plan which is:  “Leading Ontario in the development of North America’s most reliable, cost-effective and sustainable electricity system.”   The vision is certainly leading Ontario, but in the direction of being the most expensive electricity system in North America.  We just need to pass California and New York City and we will have achieved the goal!

The Business Plan also says the OPA will challenge us residential ratepayers to increase our conservation.  How, you ask?   The Plan suggests the OPA will do this: “Two other initiatives of strategic value are a pay-for-performance conservation model and a social benchmarking pilot. This pilot aims to cost-effectively reduce residential electricity consumption by providing residents with information-based tools that allow the comparison of one home’s energy performance to that of another home or group of homes. Results from the social benchmarking pilot will be analyzed and used for recommending next steps on developing such a program across the province.”

What? They are now going to shame Ontario electricity customers by applying the “trained seal” approach and presumably award “pay-for-performance” to those who train us?  Set communities against one another?

This is some “business plan.”

The OPA commits to spending $4.7 billion ratepayer dollars and gets the blessing of the Minister without a single question!   Life is good when Chiarelli is your boss and there are 4.5 million ratepayers to pick up the tab.

©Parker Gallant

September 18, 2014


Views expressed are those of the author.



Thanks Parker for looking into these issues!

Social benchmarking is another conditioning tool used on the public.

And some of the parties engaged in this social benchmarking across North America have already been identified.

This information can be supplied again if necessary.


Well, that’s a paltry $1044/ratepayer. Isn’t that just play money for you all?


Wikipedia, O Power Inc., Arlington, VA

Science & Technology section:

“Opower Energy reports incorporate the behavioral science technologies of Robert Cialdini, Opowers chief scientist and author of ‘Influence’, a 1989 book on persuasion.”

Another case for Julian?


Simple Energy, Boulder,Col. founded 2010

“Using behavioral tactics and day-of-use messaging, we drive significant load reductions during peak times.”

Clients include: Milton Hydro

Also view Wikipedia : Simple Energy


SeeWind Design Corp., Ottawa founded 1994

SeeWind Design owns or operates SwitchHop, Energy Management, Ottawa. Hydro One customers sign up for “benchmarking” reports at:

Some other Ontario utilities also use SwitchHop for “benchmarking” reports.

Complex inter – company set up.

convert soundcloud To mp3

Good post. I learn something totally new and challenging on websites
I stumbleupon every day. It’s always helpful to read through articles from other authors and practice a little something from other web sites.


If they are still asking their doctor, is there a proven cure for genital herpes and not
having any success with their treatment,
then they probably aren’t using it. Patients with symptomatic
or asymptomatic recurrences can transmit infection to sexual partners.

2006), it’s apparent that many women are safely
having babies despite having herpes.

Martial Arts Stores

Have the parent work with them as often as possible and they’ll
learn it in no time. Not only that, but the use of higher level abilities
brings a sheen of consummate role playing styled gaming to the third-person action title.
Its eventual popularity in World and Regional Games and
in the 1964 Olympic Games led more and more to an emphasis on the physical and
competitive aspects of the art, sometimes at the expense
of its intellectual, moral and spiritual underpinnings.

read more

Finally, it’s usually a great idea to come up with an expense range before searching for
products. We coasted down into Buena Vista, enjoying the view in the valley and
observing the other Sunday drivers on the highway.
) Make a map that will bring out active energy, have
them climbing under chairs, over couch, down and up
stairs etc to go on a treasure hunt.

3 week diet download

I read this article completely on thee topic of the
comparison of newest and earlier technologies, it’s amazing article.

the sims walking dead season 4 amazon

When you have no other conservative options left your physician may require you to have surgery to help treat your knee.

They grow in various fields where they generally compete with
crops for soil nutrients, water, space and light. After complying with the process, your account will become phone verified.

adele weight loss

Good post. I learn something totally new and challenging on sites I stumbleupon on a
daily basis. It’s always useful to read through
articles from other authors and use something from other websites.


Please let me know if you’re looking for a article author
for your site. You have some really good articles and I think I would be a good asset.
If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d absolutely
love to write some content for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine.
Please shoot me an email if interested. Regards!

Leave a Reply to BarbaraCancel reply


email* (not published)