Huron County wind turbine noise investigation launched

Home in Huron County: Finally, tracking wind turbine noise complaints — the government isn’t doing it [Photo Gary Moon]
November 11, 2017

Here is an excerpt from a report on the recent meeting in Clinton, announcing the launch of the Huron County public health investigation into wind turbine noise.

A few notes: as far as we are aware, the “study” is actually an “investigation” under the Health Protection and Prevention Act of Ontario, in which reports of adverse health effects may be reported and investigated. The only association with the University of Waterloo was the review by the ethics committee of that university — the university is not involved in any other phase of the project.

Wind Concerns Ontario had proposed to carry out Phase II of the study which would involve follow-up measurements in homes identified as problematic by the Health Unit, as part of a research study by a multi-disciplinary team. Although federal government funding was not achieved for that proposal, efforts to fund that initiative are ongoing.

This project is the first of its kind in Ontario; it was initiated based on reports of adverse health effects by residents of Huron County made to their health unit, and is supported by them.

For more information about the Huron County Health Unit project please visit the website here.

 

Huron County Health Unit launches wind farm study

By John Miner

ONTARIO FARMER November 7, 2017

Huron County’s on-again, off-again study on the health impact of wind farms is moving ahead with warnings from the researchers about what it can’t accomplish.

Even if the results in the end definitely show that wind farms are damaging the health of residents, the county’s health unit will not be able to order the turbines stopped, a public meeting was told.

“We do not have the authority to curtail or shut down wind turbines. If you are thinking of participating in the study in the hope that we will shut down the turbines, we want you to understand we cannot do that,” Dr. Erica Clark, an epidemiologist with the Huron County Health Unit, announced at the start of a public information session attended by about 60 people.

Courts have determined that Ontario health units do not have the legal ability to issue orders to protect public health in cases where the provincial government has given that responsibility to another body, Clark said.

In the case of wind farms, the government has given the power to regulate wind turbines to the Ministry of the Environment, not public health units, she said.

Dr. Maarten Bokhout: “If research indicates there are health issues, that can be raised with the Ontario government”

Dr. Maarten Bokhout, Acting Medical Officer of Health at the Huron County Health Unit, said while he cannot step on the Environment Ministry’s toes and he does not have the power to write orders against wind turbines, the results of the study will be published online, including interim reports.

The health unit’s one-year study, established in collaboration with the University of Waterloo and reviewed by the university’s ethics committee, will look at how people are annoyed by noise, vibration and light [shadow flicker] from wind farms.

The goal is to establish how many people are bothered by wind turbines in the county and determine if environmental conditions that make the noise, vibration light and sensations from wind turbines worse.

The study will rely on residents living within 10 km of a wind turbine who volunteer to keep a diary of their experience within their own home.

Participants are asked to record their observations at least once a week.

The researchers will not be making any actual sound or vibration measurements for the study.

Huron County is home to more than 300 industrial wind turbines and some of the largest wind farms in the province.

Some residents have blamed the turbines for a series of health problems, including headaces, nausea, dizziness and insomnia.

Clark, who is principal investigator on the study, said they want participation from both people who have been bothered by wind turbines and those who haven’t experienced any problems.

The 10-kilometre study zone around wind turbines means thousands of Huron County residents are eligible to sign up for the project, including all of the towns of Goderich and Exeter.

See the print edition of Ontario Farmer for a related story: Rural residents skeptical government would act on wind

Comments

Stan Thayer
Reply

Yes the IWT’S do cause harm to people, that is official.
My biggest concern is for the affordability of the Ontario electrical system.
I spent months in 2016 helping to upgrade the main transformer station behind the Boston Pizza in Goderich where some of the IWT’s feed in. The wild power fluctuations of the IWT’s present peculiar problems for the grid controllers so costly attempts are being made to minimize the effects.
Yesterday, November 10 2017, the average low for all the IWT’S in Ontario during hour 19 was a contribution of 14MW into a grid demand of 14,000MW.
IWT’S are the most inefficient, problematic and costly way to produce poor quality electrical power and should only be used on a commercial scale as a last resort in area’s where nothing else is viable.
Another type of harm is the money being paid to international corporations by the Liberal government regulations for the IWT’S is taxpayer dollars leaving the province.
That harms everyone.
And I can prove that!
Stan the power man

Notinduttondunwich
Reply

My question is …..
How does this study take into account abondoned properties?? If the study is ongoing and you can’t reside in your home then how is this accounted for?? Are those folks that have abondoned their property due to health issues still included in this study or is that property nullified by default or (no one lives here so we can’t test) …

Somewhat like what is happening in CK.. your water has so much turbitity that we can’t test it thefefore it is inconclusive!!!

Wind Concerns Ontario
Reply

An investigation that is based on citizen reports of excessive noise/vibration and any perceived associated health effects cannot deal with abandoned properties.

Richard Mann
Reply

Can the health board consider the 26 written complaints already submitted to the Health Board in March 2016? They are written down in the comments here,
http://cmajblogs.com/health-canada-and-wind-turbines-too-little-too-late/

How is it ethical to continue collecting more data when we know already there is health harm? Even the ERT admitted that there is health harm, it is just a matter of degree.

Will Dr Bokhout, MD respond to citizens in his community? Does he believe their reported health harm is real? If so, as a medical doctor he has a moral and ethical responsibility to report the harm to the Government.

The Health Board says they cannot order the turbines turned off, but they can make a request of our government.

After this it is up to the government to act or ignore this advice.

Richard Mann
University of Waterloo

John Miner
Reply

Additional information:

The principal investigator for the research study is Dr. Erica Clark, who is an adjunct professor University of Waterloo. Collaborators for the study are Dr. Phillip Bigelow, Associate Professor University of Waterloo; Dr. Olaf Berke, Associate Professor University of Guelph; Dr. Maarten Bokhout, Acting Medical Officer of Health, Huron County Health Unit; and Jean-Guy Albert, public health manager, Huron County Health Unit.

Leave a comment

name*

email* (not published)

website