MOECC staff knows about wind turbine health effects, WCO tells Minister

Environment Minister says health concerns “bogus” — staff acknowledge health problems in official records

Home in Huron County: the Minister says claims of health effects from turbine noise are “bogus” but his staff say different [Photo Gary Moon]
Last week, following a report by Global News based on information obtained by Wind Concerns Ontario, there was a barrage of questions in Question Period at Queen’s Park on wind power projects and related issues, including reports of adverse health effects from exposure to the noise emissions from the power generators.

In response to a question from MPP Laurie Scott of Haliburton-Kawartha-Brock, Minister of the Environment and Climate Change Glen Murray tossed back:

This government spent a considerable amount of money hiring the leading experts and doing medical research, as did the federal government, and found out the totality of the opposition party’s claims were completely bogus and like so much, not science-based.

In fact, the “science” the Minister Murray refers to, including the Health Canada study, supports concerns about adverse health effects from wind turbine noise, and the Chief Medical Officer of Health for Ontario produced a brief review in 2010 that concluded that there were significant gaps in the information available at that time (seven years ago) and that actual noise measurement was needed.

But what the Minister seems not to know, says Wind Concerns Ontario, is that his own staff are aware of people experiencing health effects from wind turbine noise, according to official staff notes included in the information received n the Freedom of Information request. That information consisted of 3,180 Incident Reports and 100 Master Incident reports; several of the Master files contain dozens of reports to the government about the turbine noise and vibration, and include staff observations.

“It is very disturbing that a Minister of the Crown could be so dismissive of the health concerns of Ontario citizens,” Wind Concerns Ontario president Jane Wilson wrote in a letter to Minister Murray, sent yesterday. “While the view that there is no link between wind turbine noise emissions and any health effects may be that of the wind power development industry and its trade association, it is not supported by the Master Incident complaint records that your Ministry released to Wind Concerns Ontario via a request under Freedom of Information legislation.”

Of the 100 Master files, 59 contain specific reference to health complaints, Wilson said, chiefly loss of sleep, headache, and feelings of “pressure.” Some people reported not having slept for weeks, due to the noise.

“It is therefore completely inaccurate to say that there are no health effects from wind turbine noise in Ontario,” Wind Concerns advised the Minister.

In several records, staff noted that wind turbine noise exceeded regulations: ““Staff have attended at the complainants homes on multiple occasions … noise measurements were obtained…subjective observations were made by Provincial Officers…the conclusion of the POs were that the noise emissions from the wind turbines were causing an adverse effect contrary to S. 14 (1) of the EPA at the complainants locations…”

““…the conclusions of the Provincial Officers who conducted the inspections that the sound discharged into the natural environment by the wind turbines would cause an adverse effect…” was the staff note in another official record.

Wind Concerns Ontario, a coalition of 30 community groups and individuals and families, is asking that no new Renewable Energy Approvals be granted to wind power projects — five projects received contracts in 2016 but which do not have approval yet from the Environment Ministry.

“You have to ask why the government is treating the wind power industry and these huge corporations differently from other businesses,” Wilson says. “If this were any other product or service, with thousands of complaints, there would be a halt to exposure… instead, the Ontario government refers to the wind corporations as its ‘client’. We think the government should answer to the people of Ontario.”

 

 

Comments

Sommer
Reply

It’s time for open letters to be written to Minister Glen Murray, from all of the communities where harm is still being experienced from turbines near homes and farms. These open letters need to be circulated widely so that the people of Ontario will no longer be deceived. These letters need to contain concise statements regarding the truth about the harm being experienced because the MOECC, currently under the direction of Minister Murray, has failed their duty to protect rural residents.
This has clearly been an ‘industry led, government enabled’ fiasco.
Now is the time….

Grant Church
Reply

In the ERT decision on Erickson v. Director, Ministry of the Environment it was ruled that the evidence showed that wind turbines cause health problems, “This case has successfully shown that the debate should not be simplified to one about whether wind turbines can cause harm to humans. The evidence presented to the Tribunal demonstrates that they can, if facilities are placed too close to residents.”

Sommer
Reply

“if facilities are placed too close to residents.” is the loophole the MOECC has used consistently. The policy protocol on placement was set at a specific distance and they have refused to acknowledge that this was a mistake. Residents have tried to tell them their policy on siting is wrong. We know now from the reporting of harm, that people whose homes are located a wide range of distances from turbines are experiencing harm.

Mike Jankowski
Reply

Well said Jane and team. I also wrote Mr. Murray encouraging him to get in touch with his own team and further questioned whether the MoE standards are adequate, which I know them not to be. Unacceptable performance by this minister, failing in their most important mandate.

Stan Thayer
Reply

I think the time for discussion ran out years ago or these situations would have been dealt with years ago. The lies and deception tell me all I need to know about this government.
Good luck.
Stan Thayer

Richard Mann
Reply

According to Huron County, they are still waiting on University of Waterloo for ethics approval. I have documented all my correspondence with Huron County on my web page,
http://www.cs.uwaterloo.ca/~mannr

A (legally mandated) Health Investigation was started in March 2016.
Since then there have been numerous delays. On May 12, 2017, Huron Health Board sent a letter claiming that they lack the authority to turn the turbines off.

There appears to be no remedy for those living under turbines.

Barbara
Reply

Canada | NRDC

Scroll down to:

“We’re working to expand trade in clean energy and the enormous potential; identify ways that Canada’s provinces can provide states with the clean energy supplies needed to meet carbon-reduction targets; and make the air cleaner and healthier on both sides of the border.”

More at:
https://www.nrdc.org/canada

Barbara
Reply

CEAA Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency, Oct.9, 2012

Joint Review Panel: Jackpine Mine Expansion Project

“Re: Earthjustice and ecojustice written submission to the Jackpine Mine Expansion Project”

Read at:
http://www.ceaa.gc.ca/050/documents/p59540/83149E.pdf

Also use internet search: Earthjustice + Canada

Notinduttondunwich
Reply

Ya Barbara that’s what I’m talking about!!!! We pay top dollar so that the liberals clients’ clients can have cheap green hydro!!!
Mark my words when I say the this Lieberal government will impose rolling blackouts on all Ontarions if it’s clients’ clients require more power…. always important to keep the lieberals clients happy right!!??
Right now in Michigan they are negative power right now …. which means they need supply.. we will supply it… guaranteed ….. below market value…..

Barbara
Reply

Ya, and this was predicted to happen in Michigan this June. There is still Monday and Tuesday to go in Michigan which are work days and temperatures around 90 F.

If you look at the 2006 Supreme Court records you will see that Michigan opposed the court Proceedings (Mass. v. EPA).

Michigan also voted in 2012 not go 25/25, or 25 % renewables by 2025.

It’s not the people of Michigan who are causing these problems.

Barbara
Reply

(Mass. v. EPA) 2006

Parties

Click on : ‘Brief of States in Opposition’

Included:

Michigan
Ohio
And other states

There is a list of states for the Proceedings too.

Barbara
Reply

Re: FERC/PJM Interconection Case, Petition filed July 8, 2016

U.S. Court of Appeals, D.C. Circuit, Washington, D.C.

Case No.16-1234 or # 16-1234

AWEA is listed as an Intervenor in this Case

The case number is required to locate online information on this Case.

Barbara
Reply

‘Canadian Hydro Power And the Clean Power Plan’, April 2015

Contents: P.19

‘The Clean Power Plan’s Approach To International Hydro Power Imports’

P.20
Re: Comments by Sierra Club & Earthjustice and renewable energy sources in foreign countries such as Canada.

More at:
https://canadahydro.ca/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/C2ES-Report.pdf

Barbara

Canadian Hydropower Association

Canadian Hydro and the U.S.

‘5 Reasons Americans Should Care About Canadian Hydropower’

2. Canadian Hydropower Delivers Competitive, Sustainable Energy

Keeps rates low for American and Canadian customers

Can help facilitate additional wind and solar power projects in the U.S.

At:
https://canadahydro.ca/facts/5-reasons-americans-should-care-about-canadian-hydropower

Barbara

The Brattle Group – News, June 28, 2016

‘Report by Brattle Economists Provides Guidance on Enabling Canadian Energy for Clean Power Plan Compliance’

“Canada is rich with clean energy resources.”

Follow the link to the June 2016 Report

At:
http://www.brattle.com/news-and-knowledge/news/report-by-brattle-economists-provides-guidance-on-enabling-canadian-clean-energy-imports-for-clean-power-plan-compliance

Re: Regarding Canadian electricity imports to the U.S. to comply with the U.S. Clean Power Plan.

Barbara
Reply

C2ES/Center For Climate And Energy Solutions, Arlington, Virginia, U.S.

Re: Articles on Canada. Click on article titles to read the articles on Canada.

Board includes:

Theodore Roosevelt, IV, Barclays Capital
David Hone, Shell International, Ltd.
Ann Klee, GE

At:
http://www.c2es.org/search/common?text=Canada

Barbara

IETA/International Emissions Trading Association

‘The International Emissions Trading Association (IETA) emerged from the United Nations Conference on Trade And Development Policy Forum on greenhouse gas emissions trading in 1999.”

Directors include:

David Hone, Chief Climate Change Adviser, Shell
Ed Ma, Senior Advisor, Suncor
Daniele Agistini, Enel
Christine Faure-Fedigan, GDF Suez
Arthur Lee, Chevron
And others

http://www.ieta.org/Governance

Richard Mann
Reply

Dear WCO and others:

Here is my latest correspondence, with Huron County Health Unit, and others, pasted from my web page.

I am asking that we stop all experimentation on humans.
Health issues are known. Turbines need to be turned off until they can be proven safe.

Richard Mann
Associate Professor, Computer Science

Richard

I have communicated this to numerous people, and no one is taking this issue seriously.

Here is an time line of my correspondence with Huron County and others. It is form my webpage, pasted below.

Thanks,
Richard

Richard Mann
Reply

(previous letter garbled, please read this one …)

Dear WCO and others:

Attached is my latest correspondence, with Huron County Health Unit, and others (pasted from my web page).

I am asking that we stop all experimentation on humans.
Health issues are known. Turbines need to be turned off until they can be proven safe.

Richard Mann
Associate Professor, Computer Science

Richard
https://cs.uwaterloo.ca/~mannr/

Correspondence from Erica Clark, Huron County Health Unit. June 6, 2017. Email (text).

Correspondence from Erica Clark, Huron County Health Unit. May 23, 2017. Email (text).

Meeting with Professors George Dixon (VP, University Research), John Thompson (Associate VP, University Research) and others. May 17, 2017.

Correspondence from Erica Clark, Huron County Health Unit. May 12, 2017. Email (text).

Correspondence from Erica Clark, Huron County Health Unit. May 2, 2017. Email (text).

Tri-Council Policy Statement. Ethical Conduct for Research Involving Humans. Link. Submission, University of Waterloo (PDF). Submission, Carmen Krogh (PDF).

Meeting with Professors George Dixon (VP, University Research) and John Thompson (Associate VP, University Research) Jan 9, 2017.

Letter to Erica Clark, Epidemiologist, Huron County Health Board. 5 December 2016 (PDF).

Huron County (Ontario). Health Board Investigation on Wind Turbine Noise. Initiated 7 March 2016. Stalled June 1 2016. HCHU meeting (4 Aug 2016, Transcript (PDF)). HCHU Public meeting (6 December 2016 (Link, Another Link (facebook), Transcript (PDF) ).

Professor denied access to Health Canada wind turbine data (Wind Concerns Ontario, May 20, 2015)
Select Committee on Wind Turbines – Parliament of Australia. Submission #408, May 3, 2015 (PDF).

Richard Mann
Reply

Dear WCO and others:

Here is an update on HCHU Investigation.

University of Waterloo Human Research Ethics Committee (as of Jun 15 2017). Application was submitted by Phil Bigelow (faculty Waterloo) and Erica Clark (adjunct appointee Waterloo and Huron County Health Unit).

Details on my web page,
http://www.cs.uwaterloo.ca/~mannr

Notinduttondunwich
Reply

Hey Sommer…. spoke to a young chap the other day who’s beautiful country home is right under a proposed turdbine site in DD …..
He’s mad as ….. heck…. each month for the last 6 months he has written an open letter to premier wynnde…. every month for 6 months… he has heard nothing…. nothing…..
Stan…. there is no discussion out here… people can’t be heard cause they are not listening… there is no contact with our municipality…. were supose to just let the lieberals clients do as they wish!!!!
Its folks like that young family that are furiuos now…. just wait and see what happens when you treat people like that … I know those people…. I know pretty well every one of the families out here that have them turdbines going up around them…. furious ……. just furious…. just saying….

Sommer
Reply

I hope they turn their anger into effective proactivity.

This is a very critical juncture. The hard work and persistence of so many wonderful people has exposed this deceptive government for all to see.

This is no time to ‘roll over and play dead’.

Notinduttondunwich
Reply

Lol…. Sommer….. there will be no rolling over!!! All these people are done trying to communicate to our government…. they have been ignored …. disrespected…. and treated like second class citizens….. these folks know that if THEY do not defend their property their ways of live out here it will be lost.. .. forever….
Our “proactive” choices to stop these projects are limited by the powers that be….

Leave a comment

name*

email* (not published)

website