Final arguments in Amherst Island appeal: danger to turtles and people?

The Whig-Standard, June 7, 2016
By Elliot Ferguson
The public waits for the start of the final day of the Amherst Island ERT. Elliot Ferguson/The Whig-Standard

The public waits for the Amherst Island hearing to begin June 7th. Photo: Elliot Ferguson/Whig-Standard

STELLA — The two sides in the legal battle over the Amherst Island wind energy project laid out their final submissions Tuesday.
The Association to Protect Amherst Island (APAI) is seeking the revocation of a conditional approval of Windlectric’s wind power project.
The hearing comes after the association appealed an August decision by the Ontario government that gave the project conditional approval. The Amherst Island Island Environmental Review Tribunal is expected to be the largest such hearing since the process was established.
Island resident Amy Caughey led off the final submissions by arguing that the negative effects on children’s health have not been studied collectively.
Caughey said the proximity of a proposed concrete batch plant near Amherst Island Public School would hurt pupils’ health.
But Caughey said such effects can’t properly be studied unless the children are first exposed to the dust and noise from the plant and the changes in their health documented.
“In Canada, in 2016, we do not permit such trials on children,” she said. “The burden of proof cannot fall on a parent.”
APAI’s lawyer, Eric Gillespie, said the evidence has met the burden of proof needed to show wind turbines are detrimental to human health.
“This case advances the health claims further than any other case this tribunal has heard,” he said, before outlining the key evidence his witnesses presented about the potential negative impacts of the wind turbines.
Gillespie said expert testimony showed Amherst Island is home to many species — birds, bats and turtles — that could be negatively affected by the project.
“This island is a stronghold for species that is under pressure,” he said of the local bobolink population.
Gillespie saved his final submission for the Blanding’s turtle, which has taken a special place in ERTs in this area.
The closing of the Amherst Island ERT came the day after a similar process rejected a wind energy plan for Prince Edward County.
On Monday, an ERT upheld an appeal of a nine-turbine project by the Prince Edward County Field Naturalists (PECFN), saying the installation of gates on access roads won’t adequately protect the population or habitat of Blanding’s turtles.
Gillespie said island residents called as witnesses have testified to have seen the turtle on the island. …
Read the full story here.

What's your reaction?


  • notinduttondunwich
    Posted June 8, 2016 8:03 am 0Likes

    Good luck to the APAI and their tribunal…. if the liberals turn over on the ERT decision to revoke contracts and go ahead with IWT projects in those areas there will be a public revolt!!!!! It’s time to start standing up to the GREEN ENERGY ACT!!! We will create 10 x as much pollution with this act!!!! 10 times people!!!!! This is ludicrous that the Liberals keep procuring more IWT projects!!! STOP NOW!!!!!! I’m not saying please anymore!!!!!!

  • Bert
    Posted June 8, 2016 9:00 am 0Likes

    The green energy act is Liberal dictatorship. But Ontarians don’t stand up, they let themselves be slaughtered by this Wynne government.
    The accomplishment of the green energy act is destruction of environment, waste of electric energy and more poverty in Ontario.

  • Pat Cusack
    Posted June 8, 2016 10:17 am 0Likes

    So very depressing!

Add Comment

© Copyright 2022 | WCO | Wind Concerns Ontario

to top