Parker Gallant on Hydro One: explaining the unexplainable

saveONenergy Coupons!

Norfolk Power: a good deal for somebody. Not you.

If you are, or could be in future a Hydro One customer there is no reason to cheer about their 2014 second quarter news release … unless you are a ratepayer in Norfolk.

Hydro One’s news release of August 14, 2014 stated the company has received an “approval to acquire Norfolk Power Inc. (Norfolk Power).” The sale price announced last year was $93 million.  For the ratepayers in Norfolk that acquisition will mean a five-year holiday from distribution rate increases.

But there is more: Hydro One is now committed to paying 30.4 times the annual profit of Norfolk Power for the year ended December 31, 2013. That price is referred to as the P/E (price/earnings) multiple. The purchase price by Hydro One is pure insanity as the P/E of utility companies trading in the market has traditionally been in the 10/15 times P/E range.  Why is Hydro One using taxpayer dollars to benefit only the ratepayers and taxpayers of Norfolk, and why did the Ontario Energy Board (OEB) bless the purchase?

The Hydro One press release had lots of bad news: even though revenue was up by $163 million for the quarter it was due principally to the cost of power increasing by $140 million for the additional 0.2 TWh (terawatt hours) purchased.   Doing the math on the extra 0.2 TWh shows a price of $700 per MWh (megawatt hour) or the equivalent of 70 cents per kilowatt hour.   That jump pushed the cost of power for the first six months of 2014 for Hydro One customers — up by 17.8%, and 20.5% for the recent three months.

Why is Hydro One paying so much for the additional power? Are all the other LDCs in the same position?

More bad news: Hydro One’s net income was down by $53 million (32%) in the last three months and $70 million (16%) in the first six months of the current year.  Comparing the second quarter, 2014 with the same quarter in 2013 shows that profit for Hydro One’s transmission business was up slightly, but profit for the distribution business dropped by $45 million or 53%.  What that means is Hydro One will be applying to the OEB for a rate increase for the distribution side.

This was also in the news release, related to the drop in net income:  “The reductions in net income were primarily due to higher operation, maintenance and administration costs resulting from increased aging of accounts receivable as a result of a combination of the impact of cold winter weather on customer bills based on increased electricity consumption and prices, as well as our customer service recovery initiatives.”

Translation: they are connecting the reduction of net income to “increased aging of accounts receivable” which is a stretch, unless they ramped up administration costs to collect delinquent ratepayer bills!  That might have something to do with the flawed billing system under investigation by the Ombudsman.  Or, it could have something to do with “energy poverty” as more and more Ontarians can’t pay the ramped up electricity and distribution costs.

Whatever the answer, it has obviously been caused by one or a combination of all three of these issues which are symptomatic of poor management of expenses,  faulty execution of the revamped billing system, and higher energy prices.

Higher prices are the direct result of the push for large-scale renewable power sources by the incumbent Liberal government.

Customers of Hydro One deserve an answers … and the truth.

©Parker Gallant

August 22,2014

The views expressed are those of the author.

HydroOne Logo

Comments

Doyle
Reply

For all those Liberals in TO, come and spend some time living near a wind turbine. We can no longer sleep at night with our windows open – the noise keeps us awake. There are 8 turbines that were built too high near our local airport – Transport Canada says they have to come down as they are a hazard to pilots – are they down – no. The companies are ignoring the order to remove them. Guess they are waiting for someone to get killed. People are already sick from these turbines, yet the Liberals continue to award contracts for new ones. Why not build them in TO – that is where the power is needed. Every Km the wires take the electricity looses power. Why is the best farmland in Ontario – that produces the food we all eat – being used for turbines? All around our lakes – where the birds migrate – both bats and birds dead. Bats lungs hemorrhage, birds get hit and killed. The Liberals not only pay these companies when the turbines aren’t even turning, but they have to pay the US to take our extra power on other occasions. When will their stupidity stop. When we can no longer pay our bills, when all businesses move out of Ontario as they can’t afford the hydro?

thebiggreenlie
Reply

There is not one positive thing about the Green Energy Initiative going on in Ontario BUT this dictatorial Government is “full steam ahead” on all Green Energy fronts regardless!…….that isn’t “stupidity”…………..it’s INSANITY!

Leave a comment

name*

email* (not published)

website